Dinsmore Documentation  presents  Classics of American Colonial History

Author: Fiske, John.
Title: The Dutch and Quaker Colonies in America.
Citation: Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin, 1902.
Subdivision:Front Matter to Volume II.
HTML by Dinsmore Documentation * Added October 20, 2004
← Chapter IX    Table of Contents    Chapter X →

i

Standard Library Edition

THE HISTORICAL WRITINGS

OF

JOHN FISKE

ILLUSTRATED WITH MANY PHOTOGRAVURES,
MAPS, CHARTS, FACSIMILES, ETC.

IN TWELVE VOLUMES

VOLUME VIII

ii

Illustration facing title page: William Penn (photogravure)

iii

THE DUTCH AND QUAKER
COLONIES IN
AMERICA

BY

JOHN FISKE

IN TWO VOLUMES. VOLUME II

Nieuw Nederlant is een seer schoon aengenaem gesont en lustigh lantschap daer het voor alderley slagh van menschen beter en ruymer aen de kost of gemackelycker door de werelt te geraken is als in Nederlant offte eenige andere quartieren des werelts mijn bekent. — Adrian Van der Donck, 1656.

For I must needs tell you, if we miscarry it will be our own fault; we have nobody else to blame; for such is the happiness of our Constitution that we cannot well be destroyed but by ourselves. — William Penn, 1679.

Riverside Press Logo

BOSTON AND NEW YORK

HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY

The Riverside Press Cambridge

iv

COPYRIGHT 1899 BY JOHN FISKE

COPYRIGHT 1902 BY HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO.

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

v

CONTENTS

X
THE ENGLISH AUTOCRATS
PAGE

Peaceful transfer of New Netherland to English rule

1

Admirable character of Governor Nicolls

2, 3

Carr’s shameful conduct at New Amstel

4

Fall of the Republic of New Haven

5

The Connecticut boundary

6

Yorkshire, Dukes County, and Cornwall

7

Cartwright sails for England, but lands in Spain

8

Pleasant Saturday evenings in Boston

9-11

Maverick moves to New York

11

Settlements west of the Hudson River

12

The grant to Berkeley and Carteret

12-14

Founding of Elizabethtown

14

The name New Jersey (Nova Cæsarea)

14

Unwillingness of New Haven leaders to be annexed to Connecticut

15

Exodus from New Haven to New Jersey

16

Robert Treat and Abraham Pierson

16, 17

Constitutional troubles in New Jersey

18

Lord Berkeley sells out his interest to a party of Quakers

19

Nicolls returns to England, and is succeeded by Francis Lovelace

19, 20

Abolition of the distinction between great and small burghers

21

The first mail on the American continent, monthly

vi

between New York and Boston, starts on New Year’s Day, 1673

21-24

The postman’s route

24, 25

The English towns on Long Island protest against arbitrary taxation

26

Charles IIabandons the Triple Alliance, and joins with Louis XIVin attacking Holland

27, 28

Admiral Evertsen’s fleet in the West Indies

28

Evertsen captures the city of New York, and names it New Orange

28, 29

Anthony Colve is appointed governor of New Netherland

30

The English towns on Long Island are refractory

30

Danger of an attack by the New England Confederacy

31

How Governor Colve pulled down houses to improve his fort

32-37

Lovelace’s purchases and debts

37-39

Schemes of Louis XIV.

39

Ingenious double-dealing of Charles II.

40

The treaty of Westminster restores New York to the English

41

Conflicting grants and claims

42

The duke sends Edmund Andros to govern New York

43

Character of Andros

43

His early life

44

Anthony Brockholls and William Dyer

45

Arrival of Andros in New York

45

The English towns on Long Island declare that they belong to Connecticut, but in vain

46

The oath of allegiance ; protest of leading burghers

46-48

Andros showed a want of tact in this affair

48

Demand for a representative assembly ; the duke’s letters

49-51

Andros’s zeal for municipal improvements

51

He tries in vain to reform the currency

52

vii

And fulminates against excessive tippling

53

He lays claim to Connecticut for the duke

53-54

King Philip’s War breaks out

55

Connecticut prepares to resist Andros, and Captain Bull baffles him at Saybrook

56-58

Invasions of the Mohawk country by the French

58-60

Jesuit intrigues with the Long House

60-62

Mistaken policy of the Duke of York

62

Journey of Andros into the wilderness

62

Arendt van Corlear and his melancholy fate

63

Corlear’s village, Schenectady

64

Andros arrives in the Oneida country and holds a grand pow-wow with the Indians

64, 65

He organizes a Board of Indian Commissioners

66

Robert Livingston

66

Andros’s relations with New England

67

King Philip in the Berkshire mountains

68-71

War with the Tarratines

71

Andros visits England, is knighted, and returns to New York

71
XI
NEW YORK IN THE YEAR 1680

The great comet, and how it was regarded in New York

72

Approach to New York from the harbour ; Fort James

73, 74

Pearl Street and Broad Street

74, 75

The Water Gate and Maiden Lane

75, 76

Shoemaker’s Land ; the Land Gate

76, 77

Bowery Lane and the Common

78

The Collect, or Fresh Water ; Wolfert’s Marsh

79

The Kissing Bridge ; the Bowery Village

80, 81

Kip’s Bay and Turtle Bay

81

viii

Harlem

82

The Great Kill, and Lispenard’s Meadows

83

Origin of Canal Street

84

Sappokanican, or Greenwich ; Minetta Brook

84, 85

Visit of the Labadist missionaries, Dankers and Sluyter

85-87

Their experience at the custom-house

87-89

They cross the East River and pass through Brooklyn

89-91

They are entertained at Gowanus by Simon de Hart

91

They proceed to Najack (Fort Hamilton)

92

Their description of an Algonquin household

93-96

They pass a hilarious night at Harlem, where they meet James Carteret

96, 97

They are charged a high fare for crossing Spuyten Duyvil

98

They compliment the good beer at Greenwich

99

But are not pleased with the New York dominies

100

RevJames Wolley praises the climate of Manhattan

101

His Latin supper with the Calvinist and Lutheran parsons

102, 103

Charges of heresy brought against Dominic Van Rensselaer

103-105

Estates and revenues of New York

105

Formation of an independent Classis

106

The flour monopoly

107

Affairs in New Jersey

107, 108

Andros asserts sovereignty over East Jersey

109

Carteret resists, and Andros deposes him

109, 110

Shameful arrest of Carteret

111

His trial, acquittal, and return to Elizabethtown

111, 112

The duke relinquishes East Jersey to the Carterets

113

And West Jersey to Byllinge and his friends

114

Which brings William Penn upon the scene

114

ix

XII
PENN’S HOLY EXPERIMENT

Religious liberty in Pennsylvania and Delaware

115

Causes of intolerance in primitive society ; identity of civil and religious life

116

Military need for conformity

117

Illustration from the relations of the Antinomians to the Pequot War

118

The notion of corporate responsibility

119

Political and religious persecutions

120

Reasons for the prolonged vitality of the persecuting spirit

121

Evils of persecution; importance of preserving variations

122

From a religious point of view the innovator should be greeted with welcome

123

Sir Henry Vane’s “heavenly speech”

124

Cromwell’s tolerance

125

Quietists and Quakers

126

Career of George Fox

127

Origin of the epithet, “Quaker”

128

James Naylor and other crazy enthusiasts

129

Missionary zeal of the early Quakers

130

Their great service in breaking down the Massachusetts theocracy

131

Charles IIand the oath of allegiance

132

Early years of William Penn

132, 133

His conversion to Quakerism

134

It makes trouble for him at home

135

Penn’s services to Quakerism

136

His steadfastness and courage

137

Some of his writings : “Innocency with her Open Face”

137

If you will not talk with me, says Penn, I must write

138

You call names at me instead of using argument

139

If you do not blame Luther for asserting the right of private judgment, why blame me ?

140

When you persecute others, you assume your own infallibility, as much as the Papists do

140

But you cannot hurt us, for if God is with us, who can be against us ?

141

“No Cross, no Crown”

142

Religion thrives not upon outward show

142

It is but a false cross that comports with self-indulgence

143

Religion is not a fetich, but a discipline

143

Better resist temptation than flee from it

144

The wholesomeness of solitude

145

The follies of fashion

146

“Thee” and “thou”

147-149

The use of “you” in place of “thou,” says Penn, is undemocratic

149

Memorable scene in the Lord Mayor’s court ; futile attempt to browbeat a jury

150

The recorder declares that England will never prosper until it has a Spanish Inquisition

151, 152

Penn’s marriage, and charming home in Sussex

152

He goes on a missionary tour in Holland and Germany

152

Elizabeth, the Princess Palatine

153

Anna Maria, Countess of Hornes

154

Penn preaches to the servants in the palace

154

At the inn he meets a young merchant of Bremen

155

Penn tells the ladies of his conversion

155

At which a Frenchwoman of quality is deeply moved

156

A meeting on Sunday at the palace ; emotion of the princess

157, 158

Penn takes leave, and goes to preach in Frankfort and neighbouring town

158

At Duysburg he gets a gruff greeting from Count von Falkenstein

159

xi

At Leeuwarden he has a talk with an ancient maid,” Anna Maria Schurmann

160

He rebukes some fellow-travellers

161

Historic significance of the journey

162

How Penn became interested in West Jersey

162

The founding of Salem on the Delaware

163

Beginnings of a Quaker colony in West Jersey

164

Peremptory demeanour of Andros

165

Founding of Burlington

166

Thomas Hooton’s letter to his wife

166

Penn’s idea of a democratic constitution

167

High tariffs and “spoils of office” have introduced new phases of tyranny unforeseen by Penn

168

Andros claims West Jersey for the Duke of York

168

Penn’s ingenious though defective argument

169

Final release of the Jerseys

170

Penn’s claim against the Crown

171

How he conceived the “holy experiment”

172

Boundaries of Penn’s province ; seeds of contention

173, 174

Name of the new commonwealth

175

The charter of Pennsylvania compared with that of Maryland

176

Significance of the contrast

177

Influence of the king’s experience with Massachusetts

177

Penn’s humane and reasonable policy

178

His letter to the colonists

179

A Quaker exodus

180

Penn comes to the New World

181

How Chester got its name

182

The founding of Philadelphia

182

Penn’s opinion of the country

183, 184.

The Shackamaxon treaty ; Penn’s skill in dealing with Indians

184-187

Some incorrect impressions regarding the purchase of Indian lands

187, 188

Not only in Pennsylvania and New Netherland, but

xii

in all the New England colonies, in Virginia, in Maryland, and in New Sweden, the colonists paid the Indians for their lands

188

The price paid to four Delaware chiefs for the tract between the Delaware and the Susquehanna

189

Increase Mather’s “confusion of title”

190

Unstinted credit is due to the Quakers for their methods of dealing with the red men ; nevertheless in the long peace enjoyed by Pennsylvania the controlling factor was not Quaker justice so much as Indian politics

191-194

Penn’s return to England

194
XIII
DOWNFALL OF THE STUARTS

Andros returns to England, and in his absence the duke’s customs’ duties expire

195, 196

And the collector, William Dyer, for insisting upon the payment of duties, is indicted for treason

196

The demand for a representative assembly is renewed

197

The duke grants the assembly, and sends out Thomas Dongan as governor

198

Meeting of the first assembly in Fort James

198

Death of Charles H. ; the duke becomes king

199

Dongan and the Marquis Denonville play a game of diplomacy with the Long House

200-202

Louis XIV. plans the conquest of New York

202-204

But the warriors of the Long House checkmate him by invading Canada

204, 205

James II. undertakes to improve the military strength of the northern colonies by uniting them under a single government

205

And sends out Sir Edmund Andros as viceroy

205

New York is accordingly annexed to New England

206

xiii

Tyrannical rule of Andros in Boston

207

Dr. Mather detains King William’s letter

208

Overthrow and imprisonment of Andros

208

The old governments restored in New England

209

New York is disturbed by rumours of war

210, 211

Causes of the anti-Catholic panic

212

Jacob Leisler refuses to pay duties

213

Character of Leisler

213

Popular discontent in New York

214, 215

Fears of a French attack upon the city

216

Nicholson’s rash exclamation

217

Leisler takes command of Fort James, and issues a “Declaration”

217, 218

Nicholson sails for England

218

Leisler proclaims William and Mary, and Fort James becomes Fort William

219

King William’s letter arrives in New York

220

A committee of safety appoints Leisler to be commander-in-chief

220

He assumes the title of lieutenant-governor

221

He needs revenue and revives the Colonial Act of 1683

222

His authority is defied

223

His friend Jacob Milborne returns from a visit to England

223

The French war parties

224

The situation at Schenectady

225

The massacre

226

Albany yields to Leisler

227

Election of an assembly ; Leisler calls together the first American Congress, May, 1690

228

Unsuccessful attempt to invade Canada

229

Frontenac attacks the Long House

230

The king sends Henry Sloughter to be governor of New York, with Richard Ingoldsby for lieutenant?governor

230-232

xiv

Leisler loses popularity

232

Two historical novels

232

The marriages of Leisler’s daughters

233

Arrival of Ingoldsby

234

Leisler refuses to surrender Fort William

235

Ingoldsby therefore waits

235

Leisler fires upon the king’s troops

236

Governor Sloughter arrives, and arrests Milborne and Leisler

236, 237

Trial and sentence of the Leislerities

238

Execution of Leisler and Milborne

239

Leisler’s purpose was unquestionably honest

240

His motives

241

The execution was ill-advised

242
XIV
THE CITADEL OF AMERICA

Commanding position of the Dutch and Quaker colonies

243

The war with France

244-246

Some effects of the accession of William and Mary

246

Sloughter’s representative assembly

246

Death of Sloughter ; Benjamin Fletcher comes to govern New York

247

Peter Schuyler, and his influence over the Mohawks

248-250

He defeats Frontenac

250

Party strife between “Leislerians” and “Aristocrats”

250

Fletcher rebukes the assembly

251-253

His experience in Philadelphia

253

And at Hartford

253-255

Causes leading toward the Stamp Act

255

Penn’s plan for a Federal Union

256-258

The golden age of piracy

258

xv

The pirates’ lair on the island of Madagascar

259-261

Enormous profits of the voyages

261

Effects in the city of New York

261-263

William Kidd, and his commission for arresting pirates

263, 264

Fletcher is accused of complicity with the pirates, and is superseded by Lord Bellomont

265

More party strife ; Bellomont’s levelling tendencies

266-268

The election of 1699

268

Strange rumours about Kidd ; Bellomont goes to Boston, where he receives a message from him

268, 269

How Kidd turned pirate

270

The King’s proclamation ; Kidd’s desperate situation

271-273

He lands in Boston ; is arrested and sent to London

273

His trial and execution

274

Death of Bellomont

274

Violent proceedings of the Leislerians

275

The Aristocrats petition the Crown

276

Shameful trial of Bayard and Hutchings

276

The air is cleared by the arrival of Lord Cornbury

277

The question as to a treasurer for the Assembly

278

The governorship of New Jersey is united with that of New York

279

Disputes over salaries

280

Lord Cornbury’s debauchery and debts

280

A bootless expedition against Canada

281

Visit of four Iroquois chiefs to Queen Anne’s Court

282

Arrival of Robert Hunter as governor

282

Another abortive attempt against Canada

283

Difficulty of raising money for military purposes

284

Constitutional discussions

285

Hunter is succeeded by William Burnet

286

The Caughnawagas and their trade

287

Its dangers

287

xvi

Founding of Oswego, and closer relations with the Mohawk valley

288

William Cosby comes out as governor, and has a dispute with Rip van Dam

289

William Bradford and John Peter Zenger ; their newspapers

290

Persecution of Zenger

291

An information is filed against him for libel, and his counsel, William Smith and James Alexander, are disbarred for contempt of court

292

Whereupon the venerable Andrew Hamilton comes from Philadelphia to defend him

292

The words of Zenger’s alleged libel

293-295

Departing from the English law of that time, Hamilton contends that the truth of a so-called libel is admissible in evidence

295

Great importance of the step thus taken

296

Extract from Hamilton’s speech

296-298

His peroration

298

Triumphant acquittal of Zenger

299, 300
XV
KNICKERBOCKER SOCIETY

The city of New York in 1735

301

The farm of Anneke Jans

302

Narrow limits of the province

303

Some causes of its slowness of growth

304

Comparative weakness of the Assembly

305

Whigs and Tories

306

Great value of New York at the present day as a “doubtful State “

306-308

The colonial aristocracy

308

The Connecticut type of democracy

308

xvii

Peasantry and populace of New York

309

The manors and their tenantry

310

Mrs. Grant’s description of the Schuyler manor

311

The mansion

312-314

The servants’ quarters

314

The bedrooms

315

The approaches

315

The spacious barn

316

Mrs. Grant’s description of Albany

317-320

A Flatbush country-house

320

The stoop

321

The dining-room

322

The cellar

323

The sideboard

324

Chests and secretaries

325

Beds

325

A specimen inventory

326, 327

Dress

327-329

Cheerfulness of New York

329

Amusements and holidays

330

Clubs and inns

331

Reading and literature

332

William Smith and Cadwallader Colden

332

White servants

333

Negro slaves

334, 335

The negro plot of 1712

336

The “Great Negro Plot” of 1741

337

Dread of Catholic priests

337

The war with Spain

338

Hughson’s Tavern, and the informer, Mary Burton

339

Alarms of fire

340

The alleged conspiracy ; wholesale executions

340, 341

Revulsion of feeling

342

xviii

XVI
THE QUAKER COMMONWEALTH

Friendship between William Penn and James II.

343-345

Macaulay’s hasty charges against Penn

345

The Maids of Taunton

345-347

Macaulay’s discreditable blunder

347

Penn was not awake to James’s treacherous traits

348

The affair of the Seven Bishops

349-351

Penn’s lack of sympathy with the popular feeling

351

Absurd stories about him

352

Suspected of complicity with Jacobite plots

352

Anecdote of Penn and Locke

353

William III. deprives Penn of his proprietary government

354

George Keith’s defection

355

The King restores Penn’s government

356

His return to Philadelphia

357

His home and habits

357, 358

Some democratic questions

359

Disagreements between Delaware and Pennsylvania

360

The revised charter

361-363

Reasons why Penn could not fully sympathize with William III.

363

Could Quakers fight in self-defence?

364

Penn returns to England, leaving John Evans as deputy-governor

364

Evans’s folly

365-367

Powder money

367

Penn’s wretched son

367

Misdeeds of the Fords

368

Penn’s long illness and death

369

Character and accomplishments of James Logan

370

David Lloyd

371

xix

How Benjamin Franklin sought and found a more liberal intellectual atmosphere in Philadelphia than that of Boston

372-374

Attitude of Quakers toward learning

374

The first schools in Pennsylvania

375

Printing, and the Bradfords

375-377

The first American drama

377

Beginnings of the theatre

378

Agriculture, commerce, and manufactures

379

Redemptioners

379

Negro slaves ; Quaker opposition to slavery

380

Crimes and punishments

381

Philanthropy

382

Andrew Hamilton’s tribute to Penn

383

Significance of Pennsylvania’s rapid growth

383, 384
XVII
THE MIGRATIONS OF SECTS

New York and Pennsylvania were the principal centres of distribution of the non-English population of the thirteen colonies

385

The Jews ; their fortunes in Spain

386-388

Their migration to the Netherlands

388

Arrivals of Jews in New Netherland and Rhode Island

389-391

The synagogue in New York

391

Jews in Pennsylvania, South Carolina, and Georgia

392

Huguenots ; causes of their failure in France

393

Effect of the extermination of the Albigenses

394

Defeat of Coligny’s schemes for a Huguenot colony in America

395

First arrivals of Huguenots in New Netherland

396

xx

Arrivals of Waldenses and Walloons

397

Walloon settlements on the Hudson River

397

Decrees of Louis XIV. against Huguenots

398

The dragonnades

399

The Huguenot exodus, and its lamentable results for France

399, 400

Huguenots in Massachusetts

401-403

Huguenots in New York ; beginnings of New Rochelle

403

The Jay family of Rochelle, and their migration to New York

404

Jay, Laurens, and Boudinot

405

Benjamin West’s picture of the Commissioners

405

Dimensions of the Quaker exodus from England

406

Migration of Mennonites and Dunkers to Pennsylvania

407

The Ephrata Community

408-410

Migration of Palatines to New York and Pennsylvania

410

Specimen of the Pennsylvania German dialect

410

The name “Scotch-Irish”

410, 411

The Scotch planting of Ulster

411

Exodus of Ulster Presbyterians to America

412

Difference between Presbyterians in Scotland and in Ireland

413

Union of the Palatinate and Ulster streams of migration in the Appalachian region

413

Fruitfulness of Dutch ideas

414, 415
APPENDIX I. SOME LEISLER DOCUMENTS.

A. Affidavits against Nicholson

417

B. Leisler’s Commission to be Captain of the Fort

418

C. Leisler’s Commission to be Commander-in-Chief

419

D. Schuyler’s Protest against Milborne

420

E. Leisler to the Officers of Westchester

421

F. Leisler to his Commissioners at Albany

422-424

G. Leisler to Governer Sloughter

424

xxi

H. Dying Speeches of Leisler and Milborne

425-431

Appendix II. Charter for the Province of Pennsylvania, 1681

432-449

Index

451

xxii

xxiii

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
PAGE

William Penn (photogravure)

Frontispiece

From the painting in Independence Hall by H. J. Wright. After the original in possession of Robert Henry Allen, Black-well Hall, County Durham, England, painted by Francis Place in 1696, when Penn was 52.

Robert Livingston (photogravure)

66

From the original painting in Albany, N. Y., in the possession of Mrs. Daniel Manning, a direct descendant.

The Duke’s plan, or a Map of New Amsterdam, in 1661

72

From a facsimile in Harvard University Library. The original manuscript is in the British Museum. A MS. facsimile, made from the original in 1858 for Dr. G. H. Moore, is now in the possession of the New York Historical Society, and is the source of all the facsimiles printed in America.

John Millers Map of New York in 1695

100

From a facsimile in Harvard University Library. The original MS. is in the British Museum.

George Fox (photogravure)

126

From the original painting by Sir Peter Lely, by the kind permission of Friends’ Historical Library of Swarthmore College, Pa.

The Pennsylvania Charter of 1701

176

From the original in the State House, Harrisburg.

Part of Holme’s map of Pennsylvania, 1683

184

From Winsor’s America. The original was printed and published in London in 1683, and it has been republished in Philadelphia in 1846, and again in 1870.

Facsimile of First sheet of Dongan Charter of 1686.

198

The first charter of the City of New York. From the original, belonging to the city, temporarily deposited in the Lenox Library.

Peter Schuyler (photogravure)

248

From the original painted in London in 1710, now in possession of the Schuyler family, Albany, N. Y.

Richard Coote, Earl of Bellomont (photogravure)

266

After an engraving in the Library of Harvard University.

William Burnet (photogravure)

286

From the original painting in the State House, Boston.

James Lyne’s Plan of New York City: W. Bradford, 1731

302

From the original in the possession of William Loring Andrews. The so-called “Bradford Map of 1728” is merely an imitation, first published in 1834 and frequently reprinted. The original Bradford map is undated, but the year of its publication is indicated nearly by the inscription “Montgomerie’s Ward,” which was first created by the Charter of 1730.

James Logan (photogravure)

370

After the only known original, in the possession of the Philadelphia Library Co.

Dinsmore Documentation  presents  Classics of American Colonial History

Valid XHTML 1.0!